Harness vs. Collar
Share
Harness vs. collar: health & comfort (complete guide)
Should you choose a harness or a collar for walks? Between comfort, biomechanics , and safety, the harness wins in most cases, while the flat collar remains useful for identification and for dogs already well-behaved on a leash. Here's a clear comparison, precise adjustments, and mistakes to avoid.
Category: Harnesses & No-Pull Leashes • Size Guide: Take measurements • Routine: Walk without pulling (15 min) • Car Safety: Harness + Seatbelt
Summary
- Anatomy & impacts (traction, breathing, cervical spine)
- When to choose a harness
- When a necklace is enough
- Perfect adjustments (Y/H harness)
- Switching from a collar to a harness in 7 days
- Myths to debunk
- Comparative table
- Common Mistakes to Avoid
- FAQ
1) Anatomy & impacts
- Collar : concentrates pressure on the cervical vertebrae , trachea and sometimes the eyes (increased intraocular pressure in some dogs, especially brachycephalic breeds).
- Y/H harness : distributes weight over the thorax and forequarters , frees the throat and neck , limits friction if properly adjusted.
Practical conclusion: for training , puppies , dogs that pull or have respiratory sensitivities , a harness is preferable.
2) When to choose a harness
- Puppies or dogs learning to walk .
- Powerful pullers /dogs: front attachment point recommended initially.
- Brachycephals (bulldogs, pugs), sensitive trachea , neck pain .
- Sport , hiking, cycling, car (always attach to the harness with a dedicated belt).
See the selection: Harnesses & no-pull leashes • Car seat belts: Black • Red • Pink • Blue • Green
3) When a necklace might suffice
- Trained dog that walks without pulling , calm and short walks.
- Identification (medallion), garden outings , rest at home.
Choose a wide, comfortable, flat collar with two fingers' width of space . Avoid devices that cause aversion (choke collars, prongs).
4) Perfect adjustments (Y/H harness)
- Measure the chest and neck correctly.
- Position : the Y at the sternum , never on the throat; shoulders free .
- Comfort : 2 fingers under each strap (neither tight nor loose).
- 10-step test : no rotation, no upward movement of the neck, no rubbing of the armpits.
Tip: start with the front attachment if your dog is pulling, switch back to the back when the leash loosens (see 15 min routine ).
5) Transition from collar to harness in 7 days
| Day | Objective | Duration |
|---|---|---|
| J1 | Positive association with the harness (treats on/near) | 3–5 min |
| J2 | Threading + 1–2 min at home, take off before getting annoyed | 5–7 min |
| D3 | A short stroll through the corridor/garden, enhancing the gaze | 5–10 min |
| Days 4–5 | Smooth U-turns + thigh rewards | 2 x 5 min |
| J6 | A calm exit with 2-3 controlled sniffing breaks | 10–15 min |
| J7 | Usual route short, reinforcements random | 15 min |
6) Myths to debunk
- “The collar educates better.” — Learning depends on the timing of rewards and the management of the environment , not on an attachment point that compresses the throat.
- “The harness makes the horse pull.” — A poorly adjusted harness can encourage pulling, but a Y-harness + front attachment helps regain control during training.
- “All harnesses are the same.” — Look for free shoulders, a low sternal strap, padding where it's needed, and a wide adjustment range .
7) Comparative table
| Harness (Y/H) | Flat collar | |
|---|---|---|
| Breathing comfort | ✅ Free throat | ⚠️ Possible pressure on the trachea |
| Neck protection | ✅ Chest/shoulder distribution | ⚠️ Neck pull-ups |
| Pull-free learning | ✅ Useful front attachment | ⚠️ Less favorable if the dog is pulling |
| Identification | ✅ Possible (medallion on harness) | ✅ Very practical |
| Car | ✅ To attach to the belt | ❌ Do not attach to the collar |
8) Common mistakes to avoid
- ❌ Harness too high on the throat → breathing difficulties.
- ❌ Straps too loose → reverse exits.
- ❌ Aversive collars (choke collars, prong collars) → physical & emotional risks.
- ❌ Do not recheck the settings after a few rides.
FAQ – Harness vs. Collar
What choice for a puppy?
A Y-shaped harness , wide adjustment range, short and positive training sessions. See: Puppy harness: mistakes to avoid .
Does the harness cause pulling?
No, not if you follow a learning routine and use the front attachment at the beginning.
Can I attach the car seatbelt to the collar?
Never. Always use a harness via a dedicated belt (see our guide ).
My dog already walks well on a collar:
Keep a comfortable flat collar for ID, and a harness for car rides, sports or long outings.